On Sale

Prepare to be swept away by our Cookie Butter Blast Sugar Cookies Recipe. These cookies are a fusion of creamy cookie butter goodness and the comforting warmth of a classic...

Discover the nostalgic flavors of our Diner Delights Bundle featuring Buttermilk Maple Flapjack and Scrumptious Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies. Indulge in the comforting taste of buttermilk and maple syrup in every...

Experience the irresistible nostalgia of our Double Malted Milk Sugar Cookies Recipe. These cookies are a delicious blend of rich malt flavor and buttery sweetness, offering a unique twist on...

Transport yourself to sunny days with our Dreamy Orange Creamsicle Sugar Cookie Recipe. These cookies capture the nostalgic flavors of a classic creamsicle, blending tangy orange zest with creamy vanilla....

Delight in the flavors of summer with our Farmer's Market Bundle sugar cookies! Indulge in the Prized Peach Melba, where juicy peaches meet creamy raspberry swirls, and savor the Blueberry...

Indulge in the sunshine state with our Florida Fresh Orange Sugar Cookie Recipe! Bursting with zesty citrus flavor and a hint of sunshine in every bite, these cookies will transport...

This zingy Fresh Raspberry Royal Icing tastes like you're eating freshly picked raspberries on a summer afternoon. It pairs well with many recipes in the Recipe Shop and will curb...

Experience a burst of tropical delight with our FruitFULL Bundle sugar cookies! Dive into the Pineapple Mango Sunrise, where sun-ripened mangoes and juicy pineapples dance on your palate. Then, savor...

Celebrate a burst of color and flavor with our "Green with Rainbows!" cookie collection! Enjoy the refreshing coolness of the Triple Midnight Mint and the playful sweetness of Rainbow Chocolate...

Indulge in pure sweetness with our Heavenly Honey Royal Icing Recipe! Perfectly crafted to complement your favorite baked treats, this icing combines the natural richness of honey with a velvety...

Delight in the golden sweetness of our Honey Bundle! Experience the unique blend of savory and sweet with the Sweet Honey Mustard Pretzel Sugar Cookie. Then, top it off with...

Experience the serene flavors of our Lavender & Honey collection! Delight in the delicate floral notes of the Lovely Honey Lavender Sugar Cookie, perfectly paired with our Heavenly Honey Royal...

Celebrate in style with Lolly's Birthday Bash Sugar Cookie Recipe! These cookies are a festive treat, bursting with colorful sprinkles and a hint of vanilla. Perfect for any birthday party,...

Savor the tranquility of our Lovely Honey Lavender Sugar Cookie Recipe. Delicately infused with floral lavender and sweetened with natural honey, each bite offers a moment of pure relaxation. Perfectly...

Enjoy the nostalgic flavors of Mr. Lolly's Fave Bundle! Dive into the rich, malted goodness of our Double Malted Milk Sugar Cookies, reminiscent of old-fashioned milkshakes. Pair them perfectly with...

Introducing our NEW Deliciousness Bundle! Indulge in a trio of irresistible flavors with our Positively Classic Neapolitan, Double Malted Milk, and Sensational Snickerdoodle Sugar Cookie Recipes. Experience the timeless combination...