Add recipes to cart & see the bundle discount appear!
(Your FREE Pumpkin Cream Pie will not show in cart & will automatically be sent to you after purchase.)

Sugar Cookie Recipes

Sort by:
Positively Classic Neapolitan Sugar Cookie Recipe

Positively Classic Neapolitan Sugar Cookie Recipe

$15.00$12.00
A new recipe just entered Cookie Town and, oooh, it’s a classic! This delicate combo of chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla is positively perfect in every way. Even rolling them out...
Buttermilk Maple Flapjack Sugar Cookie Recipe

Buttermilk Maple Flapjack Sugar Cookie Recipe

$15.00$12.00
Enjoy the comforting taste of breakfast anytime with our Buttermilk Maple Flapjack Sugar Cookies Recipe. These cookies combine the warmth of buttermilk and the sweetness of maple syrup, delivering a...
Savory Everything Cutout Cookies Recipe

Savory Everything Cutout Cookies Recipe

$15.00$12.00
Inspired by the beloved Everything bagel, these cookies blend savory and sweet flavors to perfection. With a biscuit-like texture and a delightful depth of flavor, they capture the essence of...
Sweet Honey Mustard Pretzel Sugar Cookie Recipe

Sweet Honey Mustard Pretzel Sugar Cookie Recipe

$15.00$12.00
Experience the unique blend of sweet and savory with our Sweet Honey Mustard Pretzel Cookie Recipe. These cookies combine the comforting crunch of pretzels with a delightful sweetness from honey...
White Chocolate Rosemary Lime Sugar Cookie Recipe

White Chocolate Rosemary Lime Sugar Cookie Recipe

$15.00$12.00
This all-natural sugar cookie surprises you in the best way: sweet, fresh, and just a little savory. White chocolate brings the cozy comfort, rosemary adds unexpected depth, and lime brightens...
Elderflower Lemonade Sugar Cookie

Elderflower Lemonade Sugar Cookie

$15.00$12.00
Soft, sophisticated, and just a little bit storybook. This all-natural sugar cookie recipe blends bright lemon zest with a hint of elderflower for a soft, chewy bite that’s subtly sweet...