Best Sellers

This isn’t your average vanilla royal icing. It’s silky, rich, buttery, and full of deep vanilla flavor that instantly makes your cookies taste more elevated. Smooth, refined, and unmistakably vanilla,...

Delight in our Sensational Snickerdoodle Cutout Sugar Cookies Recipe. These cookies combine the classic cinnamon-sugar goodness of snickerdoodles with the fun shapes of cutout cookies. Perfectly soft and chewy with...

This recipe is inspired by the classic Girl Scout Samoa cookie, but better because all the flavors are wrapped up in a cutout cookie! Golden-toasted coconut, luscious homemade caramel, and...

Master the Art of Color with the Ultimate Color Theory Bundle! 🖼️ Combine the power of our Color Wheel and Color Theory Guide to unlock your full creative potential in...

  Savor the perfect blend of tart cranberries and zesty orange in our Candied Cranberry Orange Sugar Cookies Recipe. Each bite bursts with fruity freshness and a hint of sweetness...

Made with rich butter and fragrant vanilla, these cookies capture the essence of the beloved classic. The tender–yet still chewy–buttery cookie packs just the right amount of sweetness, where every...

Bring the buttery, nostalgic flavor of homemade caramels to your cookies—without compromising your icing. This smooth, flavor-packed royal icing tastes just like chewy Christmas caramels and creamy caramel sauce. Made...

Introducing our Very Red Velvet Sugar Cookies Recipe, where the classic red velvet flavor meets the charm of a tender sugar cookie. These cookies boast a rich cocoa flavor with...

This class is a first here at Lolly’s as we’ve created a class that blends TWO forms of baking: Cake and Cookies! There’s no better duo than that! Get ready...

Chewy toffee sweetness meets the perfect cut-out cookie. Chewy, buttery, and loaded with sweet toffee pieces, these cut-out cookies bake up soft and full of caramel-like treasures while holding their...

Molasses paired with maple feels so right when the air gets crisp and leaves start turning. These cookies hit all the right notes: Chewy, flavorful, and naturally sweetened with maple...

Sweet morsels of caramel dance with rich pecans doused in warm brown sugar mixed with luscious cream—and lots of love.   Due to the digital nature of this product, we...

The pistachios are mellow, just nutty enough, and add a bit of a crunch when you bite in. Sweet, glace cherries shine through like rubies, but edible! They’re like fruitcake...

This zingy Fresh Raspberry Royal Icing tastes like you're eating freshly picked raspberries on a summer afternoon. It pairs well with many recipes in the Recipe Shop and will curb...

Soft, sweet, and shockingly satisfying—without the refined sugar. This all-natural base dough gives you flexible sweetening options like monk fruit, allulose, agave, or coconut palm sugar (my fave for that...

This decadent, tastebud-tested new flavor includes chewy caramel and that brown butter deliciousness...all encompassed in a cookie. Due to the digital nature of this product, we are not able to...