Recipes

Enjoy the nostalgic flavors of Mr. Lolly's Fave Bundle! Dive into the rich, malted goodness of our Double Malted Milk Sugar Cookies, reminiscent of old-fashioned milkshakes. Pair them perfectly with...

Introducing our NEW Deliciousness Bundle! Indulge in a trio of irresistible flavors with our Positively Classic Neapolitan, Double Malted Milk, and Sensational Snickerdoodle Sugar Cookie Recipes. Experience the timeless combination...

Experience perfection with our "Perfect Pairing" bundle featuring the Very Red Velvet Sugar Cookie and Completely Cream Cheese Royal Icing. Indulge in the rich cocoa flavor and velvety texture of...

Indulge in the delightful fusion of sweet and nutty flavors with our Positively Peanut Butter Sugar Cookies Recipe. These cookies offer a perfect balance of rich peanut butter goodness and...

Treat yourself to a burst of color and flavor with our Rainbow Chocolate Chippy Sugar Cookie Recipe. These cookies are a playful twist on the classic, combining vibrant rainbow sprinkles...

Savor the decadence of our Rich Crème Brûlée Sugar Cookie Recipe. These cookies capture the essence of the classic dessert with a creamy, caramelized sugar topping that cracks just like...

Delight in our Sensational Snickerdoodle Cutout Sugar Cookies Recipe. These cookies combine the classic cinnamon-sugar goodness of snickerdoodles with the fun shapes of cutout cookies. Perfectly soft and chewy with...

Delight in our Sweet Caramel Apple Sugar Cookies Recipe. These cookies blend the nostalgic flavors of caramel and crisp apples into every bite, offering a delightful twist on a classic...

Experience the unique blend of sweet and savory with our Sweet Honey Mustard Pretzel Cookie Recipe. These cookies combine the comforting crunch of pretzels with a delightful sweetness from honey...

Introducing our Very Red Velvet Sugar Cookies Recipe, where the classic red velvet flavor meets the charm of a tender sugar cookie. These cookies boast a rich cocoa flavor with...

Delightfully soft and chewy while sparkling sugar adds a bubbly surprise when you bite in. The sweet, blush pink colored cookie is made possible with tasty strawberries and adds just...

Deep, rich, nutty, and toasty goodness all rolled into one scrumptious recipe. It's like a warm hug from your taste buds, guaranteed to bring a burst of decadence to your...

This recipe is inspired by the classic Girl Scout Samoa cookie, but better because all the flavors are wrapped up in a cutout cookie! Golden-toasted coconut, luscious homemade caramel, and...

Feel like you're wandering through lemon groves on a bright morning, the zest of freshly picked lemons dancing on your taste buds. No artificial flavors or synthetic extracts here—just the...

Made with rich butter and fragrant vanilla, these cookies capture the essence of the beloved classic. The tender–yet still chewy–buttery cookie packs just the right amount of sweetness, where every...

This recipe starts with a sugar cookie base that’s perfectly balanced between tangy and sweet. Yes—this recipe incorporates some vinegary acid, but don’t worry, it adds just a hint of...